Employment Law Nov 7, 2026 3 min read

A “Vibe Shift” in Employment Law?

The Court of Appeal’s new interpretive framework in Baker favours contractual certainty — and Henshell offers an early window into what that looks like in practice.

Abstract graphic: a field of lines turning from one direction to another

A shift may be under way in Ontario employment law, driven not by legislative changes but by a new judicial approach. This summer, in Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc., the Ontario Court of Appeal released a significant decision about termination clauses — those clauses in employment agreements that address what an employee may be entitled to upon termination of employment. The Court of Appeal laid out a new “interpretive framework” and endeavoured to chart a direction favouring contractual and commercial certainty. The recent decision in Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways provides a window into what this new approach may end up looking like in practice.

What the employee argued in Henshell

In Henshell, the employee sued for wrongful dismissal and argued that she was entitled to common-law reasonable notice. The termination clause in her employment agreement limited her termination entitlements to statutory minimums under the Canada Labour Code, but she argued that the clause was unenforceable. Specifically, she submitted that a separate clause in her employment agreement indicated that a breach of the confidentiality policy could result in termination, and a termination on these grounds could contravene the Code.

Such an argument based on termination-related language outside the strict bounds of the termination provision has become commonplace in the wake of a 2020 Court of Appeal ruling in Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc. Under this doctrine, if any part of the termination scheme in an employment agreement is unenforceable, the entire scheme — including the termination clause proper — is rendered void. Employees and their counsel have routinely looked to ancillary documents — codes of conduct, bonus policies, equity agreements — to find problematic termination language that could undermine all the rest.

Why the argument failed

Prior to Baker, this argument may very well have succeeded. Seemingly emboldened, however, the employer in Henshell brought a pre-trial motion to establish the enforceability of the termination clause and to have the employee’s claim struck out. This proved to be an astute strategy as the employer was successful on both counts. Applying Baker, the Court refused to find that this one phrase in the confidentiality clause could negate the intention of the parties to comply with the Code, which was objectively demonstrated in the language of the termination clause itself. The Court wryly observed that the employee was “a practicing lawyer with 20 years experience” and could not have plausibly believed her own proposed interpretation.

The Court went further still. It also found the employee had failed to make out even a prima facie case for bad faith damages. She made bare allegations of being “unceremoniously” dismissed and suggested that dismissal was in fact retaliation for raising concerns about financial impropriety within the employer’s organization. The Court affirmed the employer’s right to dismiss without good faith reasons. In all, the Court dismissed the employee’s claim without the option of submitting an amended one.

While the full import of Baker has yet to be seen, Henshell suggests that it may bring about at least a temporary “vibe shift”. Employees and their counsel alike may need to be less cavalier about ignoring the employment agreement. Courts may be less open to the argument that a given termination clause is non-compliant with legislation because of minor drafting deficiencies, and perhaps less indulgent to employees, at least those, like Henshell, who seem to be sophisticated. Conversely, employers may feel slightly more secure in relying on the limitations to their liability contained in their employment agreements.

Jan Tomiska
Jan Tomiska
Associate Lawyer, Workly Law

Questions about a termination clause or an employment agreement? Email jtomiska@worklylaw.com. The content of this article is general information only and is not legal advice.

Hiring or Being Hired?
Let’s Talk.